Yesterday, I received an
email from Ms. Eileen Sy, who accused me of influencing the decision of which
people would get interviewed by C.B. Cebulski in his recent search for Marvel
comic book artists.
Below is the email from Ms.
Sy, after which you will read my reply to her, which I have decided to make
public.
Budjette,
It's a shame that you forcibly included
8 of your buddies out of 34 artists in CB Cebulski's talent search. It can now
be explained why more talented people were excluded.
Aspiring artists like us are now
questioned your credibility and looked at you as the next greedy agent of
comics artist.
I wonder why Migs Ramos is so
disillusioned with your Trese garbage. The padrino system is still alive and
kicking in person like you.
Shame on you!
===================================================
To: Ms. Eileen Sy
1
Out of the 34 artists shortlisted by
C.B. Cebulski, only two of them were my friends. They were handpicked by Mr.
Cebulski himself and his decision was not influenced by me or anyone else.
2
I am not a “comics agent” nor am I
claiming to be anyone’s “comics agent.”
3
If you view my work as “garbage” then
that is your opinion.
4
There was no “padrino system” used in
choosing those 34 artists. Everyone got a fair chance of submitting and
everyone was chosen based on what they submitted.
I know for a fact that my other friends
submitted their portfolios and they did not get into the shortlist. These
artists have won local awards for their comic book work, but Mr. Cebulski did
not pick them. If I was really “forcibly including” people into the shortlist,
then those friends of mine should’ve got in the list as well, but they didn’t.
There is no “favoritism” or “padrino
system” when it comes to National Bookstore and local comic book creators.
Miguel Ramos and National Bookstore
have shown full support to the local comic book scene, as well as support to
all Filipino comic book creators.
In the past years, they have sponsored and
supported the Metro Comic Con and the Komikon.
They recently hosted the “HeARTworks”
comic book art charity event.
They have hosted the comic book launch
of Gerry Alanguilan’s Elmer, and Superior, which was drawn by Leinil Yu and
Gerry.
Go to the branches of National
Bookstore now and you’ll see that they distribute all kinds of local comic
books: from graphic novels published by Visprint, like Kikomachine, Trese, The
Filipino Heroes League, Zsazsa Zaturnnah; to self-published comic books like Kalayaan,
Bayan Knights, Pugad Baboy, and Beerkada.
Ms. Sy, if you feel bad that you didn’t
get in the shortlist, then don’t blame it on me and don’t blame anyone else.
I have been writing comic books for the
past 22 years and I have been rejected by Marvel Comics, DC Comics, and even
Atlas Komiks.
I am lucky and blessed to have found a
publisher like Visprint, who finally accepted my work and supports the stories
I tell with Kajo. But before I found a publisher who accepted and approved of my
work, it meant I had to keep writing and keep getting rejected for 17 years.
And in the past five years, I have submitted and pitched “Trese” to Vertigo
Comics, Marvel Comics, and Image Comics and I still got rejected. But that has
not stopped me from writing more stories and from improving my craft.
In all those times I got rejected, I
blamed no one else but myself.
And as I write my next story, I make
sure that this is the best one I’ve written and hope that this will be the one
that the publishers will like and get me accepted.
Lastly,
if this were just an email critiquing my work then I would’ve probably replied
to you in private. If you really believe that my work is “garbage”, then you
are entitled to your own opinion and would feel no need to try and change that
belief.
However,
the reason I am responding publicly is because your baseless accusations casts
doubt on the recent talent search conducted by Mr. Cebulski. It is unfair of
you to say that some of them got in because of some “padrino system”.
Out
of the 34 artists, there was a good mix of professional artists (those who have
been published here and abroad) and amateur artists. There was even one who
just graduated from college. They were all chosen based on the portfolio they
submitted, based on their skill and hard work.
It
is unfair of you to say that some of those artists didn’t deserve to be shortlisted.
It is unfair of you to judge that they weren’t talented enough to be
interviewed.
I am amazed that you took the time to
sit down and write that email, make unfounded accusations, call me names and
call my work garbage, when you could’ve used that time to draw more and improve
your craft.
Keep on drawing, Ms. Sy. Just keep on
drawing.
--budjette tan
p.s. if you ever want to show your new
and improved portfolio to Mr. Cebulski, feel free to email him at : cbcebulski @marvel .com
14 comments:
So where can i find the portfolio of Eileen Sy? - Alex Arellano
So where can I find the portfolio of Ms. Eileen Sy?
well said budj!
that was a good response Budjette. Eileen Sy is an example of an artist think her works are above all of them.She thinks her work is perfect.No more room for improvement. Don't be a sore loser. Ms. sy
eileen sy needs to stop blaming others for her failures.
Budj, I wouldn't take Marvel and DC's rejection of TRESE as any kind of statement about your craft. There's probably a whole laundry list of reasons, not the least of which is marketability (it's set in the Philippines, after all). You're as good a writer as it gets.
When a 'loser' accuses someone of cheating or being biased during a competition, it just sounds like a sore loser whining. Though it is a bit understandable what may have prompted her to do this, it might hve been better if she made sure of the facts before she ranted. And lastly but sadly , this is a trait that is prevalent among us filipinos: to blame others as an excuse for failing... :(
I wonder what gave her that notion though? It sounds so ridiculous.
I submitted as well but wasn't among the chosen few. It's the second time I've submitted my portfolio to Marvel and I don't feel discouraged by striking out again. It just means, like you said, I have to keep on drawing, keep on writing.
An irrational, accusative comics fan? It's unheard of!
Budjette, I accuse you of forcibly including your favorite Marvel heroes in the movie Avengers, leaving out The Wasp, Black Goliath, Squirrel Girl and more talented heroes out there from their first big-screen adventure.
I accuse you of forcibly keeping your beloved Shane alive throughout Season 2 of the Walking Dead when he should have died at the end of Season 1 if we base it on the timeline of the comic book.
I accuse you of bringing back some of Darth Maul in Clone Wars. You've always thought of Maul as "not half-bad" ever since you watched Phantom Menace and you used your ...illusion? What's better than illusion? Ah, dis-illusion! ...on your padrino George Lucas to get your way.
Shame on you. J'accuse!
I am now very much curious to see what Ms. Sy's work looks like.
But I am a bit miffed by Arko geppeto's comment, however, that this sort of behavior is prevalent among Filipinos. It happens everywhere. Yes, even in the good ol' US of A.
To Madam (or Sir) Eileen Sy:
Try befriending and employing white dwendes (or Nuno) to draw comic pages for you. That's what talentless hacks like me do.
Avoid black dwendes. I tried them. they suck at meeting deadlines and they don't like drawing backgrounds and feet.
We dont even know if this Eileen Sy is even an artist herself, although I believe you dont need to be a good or bad comic artist to give you the right to criticize other's work or methods(ive met good readers and comic collectors who dont draw, but knows their art).
But I do agree on the fact that her letter is only meant to hurt and cast doubt, and not to improve as there are no solid evidence to back up her accusations. For all we know, this "Eileen Sy" may be a pseudonym, a mask behind another disgruntled individual who fears retaliation from an army of enraged supporters in the internet.
Whatever the case is, im glad you clarified this in your blog, as people tend to glorify/sensationalize negative traits without checking out the facts (Facebook is full of them). Neways, ill be reposting this in my FB for everyone's info.
Keep up the good work!
So, Migs Ramos is "disillusioned" with your work yet he's supposed to be one of your "padrinos"? Is she trying to be sarcastic?
Okay...sumabog ang ulo ko diyan.
Eileen is possibly a good artist. She probably just didn't get the submission instructions right.
Sorry i dont live in the US of A and therefore I dont know much to include them or the rest of the world in my comment. Though i know that it is a human trait and probably a lot of other people regardless of their nationlity may be guilty of it, i will not include them because its just like being ms sy: judging someone without proper info.
Post a Comment